Read Anne Raver of
The New York Times
In the Garden
“a dreamlike landscape”
Vistas and Close-ups,
Staged by a Filmmaker
Duncan Brine is a
Landscape Designer with
a Filmmaker’s Eye
IT had been raining all day, so mist covered the trees and shrubs as we set out for a walk through Duncan and Julia Brine’s six-acre garden, a dreamlike landscape that takes its cues from
the old shade trees and fence posts remaining from the farm that was once here, as well as the native plants, like black locust and joe-pye weed, that populate the hills and spring-fed marsh.
© John Lei, 2007
The land is part of the old Sheffield Farm, which supplied 50,000 bottles of milk a day to New York City in the 1920s and 1930s (according to the enlargement of a vintage postcard in a little restaurant in town), and the Brines have made their home and office here, in two 1920s farmhouses at the apex of the property.
It takes exactly 27 steps for the Brines to commute from the renovated farmhouse they live in to the one where they run their business, Horticultural Design Inc., across a gravelly courtyard filled with exotic plants.
“It’s all Asian, except for the elderberry,” Mr. Brine said, as I stood nose to nose with an enormous cryptomeria, or Japanese cedar, outside the office door. “The idea was to have more exotic things close to the house, and in a deer-protected area.”
The space is fenced with a combination of coarse oak planks and locust posts, as well as an occasional Japanese umbrella pine, which the deer do not eat (here, anyway).
© gardenlarge
Mr. Brine has broken every rule in the book by planting the cryptomeria right in front of the door. But this magnificent evergreen – a Yoshino, at least 15 feet tall and 6 feet wide – did not block my way. It was riveting, like an unbelievably handsome man, and caught me off guard. I forgot all my preconceived ideas about how to navigate this garden and simply started looking around.
There were callicarpas full of pale lavender berries, which would turn purple in the fall; viburnums and shrub dogwoods; and lacy elderberries juxtaposed against dense evergreens or the large, floppy leaves of an oakleaf hydrangea. There were specimen trees, like an English oak and sweet gum, both with variegated leaves, and mounding shrubs, like stephanandra, whose bright green, deeply incised leaves cascaded over black sedge grass.
“It’s stuffed with stuff,” Mr. Brine said, grinning at what he calls “an intentional arsenal of plants,” all knitted together, hiding the walls of the house we had just left. Otherwise “we’d have this building looming over us,” he said. “But as soon as you’re out the door, you’re in ga-ga land.”
“Every time I talk to a savant I feel quite sure that happiness is no longer a possibility. Yet when I talk with my gardener, I’m convinced of the opposite.”
–Bertrand Russell, philosopher, mathematician, and author (1872-1970)













4 responses so far ↓
1 Duncan Brine // Apr 16, 2011 at 8:56 am
Anne Raver first visited the Brine Garden several years ago. Last week, she remembered her visit to an attentive audience at the Horticultural Society of New York. It’s fair to say she loves our garden and we love her way with words which recreate the essence of the garden experience.
2 pauline thomas // Aug 13, 2011 at 9:52 am
we are in the UK and your amazing garden is on our retirement bucket list…xxx
3 Duncan Brine // Aug 14, 2011 at 5:31 pm
Why thank you so much Pauline.
We certainly look forward to your visit. You might find that plants that are familiar to you nonetheless look somewhat different in our garden as result of our different climate.
Even the beer is different here, we chill ours more…
Fall is our season to be open. See you.
4 Constanze Lingenthal // Feb 23, 2012 at 7:38 pm
I am looking forward to seeing your garden in October. Living in Manhattan for a couple of years I miss my garden back home in Germany and gardening in general so much!! Can’t wait to dig my hands in soil again…
Leave a Comment